SIGEM cross-withdrawal data compares schools in pairs, based on where students admitted to both choose to enroll. The ranking that comes out of this data is not very satisfying, because it compares schools one pair at a time rather than all together.
Using the Elo algorithm to rank the schools
DAUR used a well-established ranking method made famous by chess players: the Elo rating, which builds a ranking from matches between two players. Applied to schools, a match between two schools is a choice made by a student admitted to both. To compare all the schools using all the data, the original matrix was turned into a list of matches (about 25,000 a year), and these matches were played (in random order) year by year through the Elo algorithm, which awards points according to the initial probability of winning.
Classement SIGEM Elo 2021 avec le nombre d'intégrés
A long-standing stability shaken by the many mergers of the 2010s
The top five French business schools seem untouchable and keep strengthening their position, despite an unusual change in 2021.
HEC Paris, ESSEC Business School, ESCP Business School, emlyon business school and EDHEC Business School have long formed the top 5. The order is very clear, especially for the first three, each more than 550 points ahead of the next school: a 95% probability that a student admitted to both chooses it over the next one.
SIGEM ranking history (by Elo) from 2007 to 2021 (except 2020 due to non publication by SIGEM)
The gap between fourth and fifth place has always been narrower, but emlyon stayed ahead of EDHEC until this year, when EDHEC moved ahead. The Lille-born school owes this to its innovative strategy and its reputation in finance, while the Lyon school went through several setbacks (being placed under supervision and resignations, among others).
The mergers of the 2010s reshaped the top 10
Many mergers (still in place) in recent years have turned the old network of ESCs into a new set of schools with their own identities, sharing only the name of the degree (the Grande École program):
2009: Skema Business School, from ESC Lille and CERAM Business School
2013: KEDGE Business School, from ESC Bordeaux and ESC Marseille
2013: NEOMA Business School, from ESC Rouen and ESC Reims
These mergers show in post-prépa choices, with clear gains: all of them reached the top 10, leaving Toulouse, Rennes and Montpellier behind. Skema in particular overtakes Grenoble and Audencia this year and takes the coveted sixth place. Students have chosen the school more and more, steadily (+116 points a year on average since 2014, the year after its Lille, Paris and Marseille campuses were pooled in the exam).
Some mergers and acquisitions, however, turned out to be failures for the schools involved.
The failure of France Business School in 2012 (bringing together ESC Clermont, ESCEM, ESC Amiens and Brest Business School). The project was strongly criticized and actively disrupted by SIGEM and the exams, which withdrew it from recruitment in 2013 and so deprived the young school of CPGE students. The merger was canceled in 2015. Two of the four schools never returned to post-prépa recruitment, and the two that did (Brest and Clermont) lost 200 points, a sign that students had lost confidence in them.
The acquisitions of ESC Saint-Étienne by emlyon business school (in 2015) and of ESC Chambéry by INSEEC Grande École (in 2013): emlyon has lost 450 points since the year after the acquisition, and INSEEC 190 points.
ESC Pau and ISG gradually withdrew from SIGEM, a sign of how hard it is for these schools to recruit students from preparatory classes.
ENAss, which used to recruit a few students through the BCE exams, stopped post-prépa recruitment in 2015.




